| A Perfect Circle |
| eMotive (Compil.) | Reprises OGM | 2004 - Virgin Records | 3.75/5 | 3.32/5 | 3.4/5 |
| |
| Aftertaste |
| I'm lost at sea (Démo) | Emo rock | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | -/5 |
| |
| Amaran |
| Pristine in Bondage | Heavy-Metal | 2004 - Listenable Records | 6/10 | -/10 | 7.7/10 |
| |
| Amon Amarth |
| Fate of Norns | Metal Vikingisant | 2004 - Metal Blade Records | 7/10 | 7/10 | 7.61/10 |
| |
| Anthemon |
| Dystopia | Metal progressif atmosphérique | 2004 - Thundering Records | 8/10 | 8.5/10 | 7.23/10 |
| |
| AqME |
| Polaroids et Pornographie | Rock / Métal sombre | 2004 - AT(h)ome | 6/10 | 6.75/10 | 7/10 |
| |
| Aquilon |
| Intramedia | Mélange Death/Métal gothique | 2004 - Adipocere Records | 6/10 | -/10 | 6.81/10 |
| |
| Arkhon Infaustus |
| Perdition Insanabilis | Black/Death | 2004 - Osmose Productions | 8/10 | 8.26/10 | 7.71/10 |
| |
| Ascaris |
| Des Maux (Démo) | Deathcore | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 3.78/5 |
| |
| Ayreon |
| The Human Equation | Metal progressif | 2004 - InsideOut Music | 7.5/10 | 9.5/10 | 8.22/10 |
| |
| Beseech |
| Drama | Metal gothique | 2004 - Napalm Records | 5/10 | -/10 | 7.07/10 |
| |
| Beyon-d-Lusion |
| First Step to the Source (MCD) | Métal gothique atmosphérique | 2004 - Adipocere Records | 3.25/5 | -/5 | 3.25/5 |
| |
| Breakpoint |
| Strange Fruit | Heavy Rock | 2004 - Anvil Corp | 7/10 | -/10 | 7.02/10 |
| |
| Cannibal Corpse |
| The Wretched Spawn | Death Metal | 2004 - Metal Blade Records | 7.5/10 | 6.94/10 | 7.85/10 |
| |
| Cheinsow |
| 6 (Démo) | Néo brutal | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | -/5 |
| |
| Cipher System |
| Central Tunnel 8 | Death mélodique moderne | 2004 - Lifeforce Records | 7.5/10 | 8.75/10 | 6.48/10 |
| |
| Damageplan |
| New Found Power | Power | 2004 - Elektra Records | 5/10 | 6/10 | 6.94/10 |
| |
| Darkthrone |
| Sardonic Wrath | Black Metal | 2004 - Moonfog Productions | 8/10 | 8.11/10 | 7.37/10 |
| |
| Darkwell |
| Metat[r]on | Sous-metal gothique | 2004 - Napalm Records | 3.5/10 | 0.75/10 | 5.87/10 |
| |
| Data Princess |
| Pilot (Démo) | Pop rock légèrement métallisante | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 3.28/5 |
| |
| Deadsoul Tribe |
| The January Tree | Metal progressif | 2004 - InsideOut Music | 7/10 | -/10 | 7.62/10 |
| |
| Diablo |
| Eternium | Neo/Death mélodique | 2004 - Gaga Goodies | 7/10 | 7.5/10 | 8.21/10 |
| |
| Dirty Shirt |
| Different-Revolution (Démo) | Electro-indus-metal | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 1.5/5 |
| |
| Disarmonia Mundi |
| Fragments Of D-Generation | Death mélodique | 2004 - Scarlet Records | 7.5/10 | 7.94/10 | 7.46/10 |
| |
| Djeuled'vak |
| Reste A Ta Place!!! (Démo) | Fitness core | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | 2.25/5 | 3/5 |
| |
| Dol Ammad |
| Star Tales | Metal electronique symphonique | 2004 - Black Lotus Records | -/10 | -/10 | 6.25/10 |
| |
| Drudkh |
| Autumn Aurora | Black Metal atmosphérique | 2004 - Supernal Music | 8.5/10 | -/10 | 9.21/10 |
| |
| Electric Wizard |
| We Live | Stoner / Doom | 2004 - Rise Above Records | 9.5/10 | 8.64/10 | 7.91/10 |
| |
| Elend |
| Sunwar The Dead | Ambient / gothique sombre | 2004 - Holy Records | 8/10 | 8.25/10 | 8.2/10 |
| |
| Elvaron |
| The Five Shires | Heavy prog métal | 2004 - Thundering Records | 7/10 | -/10 | 7.54/10 |
| |
| Enforsaken |
| The Forever Endeavor | Death mélodique | 2004 - Century Media Records | 7/10 | -/10 | 7.26/10 |
| |
| Enslaved |
| Isa | Black Metal Progressif | 2004 - Tabu Recordings | 8.5/10 | 8.86/10 | 8.56/10 |
| |
| Ensoph |
| Opus Dementiae | Gothique avant-gardiste | 2004 - Cruz Del Sur Music | 8/10 | -/10 | 7.42/10 |
| |
| Entwine |
| DiEversity | Metal gothique pour midinettes | 2004 - Spikefarm Records | 6/10 | 6.5/10 | 7.16/10 |
| |
| Eths |
| Soma | Néo Brutal | 2004 - Sriracha Sauce | 7/10 | 6.65/10 | 7.18/10 |
| |
| ExInferis |
| Defunctus In Heresi | Métalcore/Deathcore | 2004 - Dalitech Records | 7/10 | -/10 | 7.13/10 |
| |
| Eyeless |
| Path To The Unknown | Deathcore | 2004 - Sriracha Sauce | 7.5/10 | 7.7/10 | 7/10 |
| |
| Fall Of Serenity |
| Royal Killing | Death mélodique | 2004 - Metal Age Productions | 4/10 | 7.5/10 | 6.37/10 |
| |
| Fall Of The Leafe |
| Volvere | Metal/rock gothique | 2004 - Firebox Records | 7.5/10 | -/10 | 6.2/10 |
| |
| Fantômas |
| Delìrium Còrdia | Musique Expérimentale | 2004 - Ipecac Recordings | 5/10 | 5/10 | 6/10 |
| |
| Forefather |
| Ours Is The Kingdom | Anglo-Saxon Metal | 2004 - Karmageddon Media | 7.5/10 | -/10 | 7.64/10 |
| |
| Fragments Of Unbecoming |
| Skywards | Death mélodique | 2004 - Metal Blade Records | 7.5/10 | 8/10 | 7.52/10 |
| |
| G.T.I. |
| Utopia City | Deathcore déjanté et rigolo | 2004 - Several Bleeds Records | 8/10 | 8.5/10 | -/10 |
| |
| Gadget |
| Remote | Grind | 2004 - Relapse Records | 8/10 | 7.88/10 | 7.63/10 |
| |
| Harmaa / Tenhi |
| Airut:Aamujen | Musique mélancolique | 2004 - UTUstudio | 7.5/10 | 8/10 | -/10 |
| |
| Hibria |
| Defying The Rules | Heavy/Speed Metal | 2004 - Remedy Records | 8/10 | -/10 | 7.93/10 |
| |
| Hounsi |
| Hounsi (Démo) | Fusion | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 3.06/5 |
| |
| HSK |
| HSK | Metal atmosphérique | 2004 - Autoproduction | 7/10 | 4.75/10 | -/10 |
| |
| Hypocrisy |
| The Arrival | Death mélodique | 2004 - Nuclear Blast Records | 6.5/10 | 7.81/10 | 7.84/10 |
| |
| Höküs Pöküs |
| Et au pays des fées... (Démo) | Vader au pays imaginaire | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | -/5 |
| |
| Imperanon |
| Stained | Heavy/speed extrême | 2004 - Nuclear Blast Records | 7.5/10 | 7.33/10 | 5.99/10 |
| |
| Into Eternity |
| Buried In Oblivion | Heavy / Prog / Death mélodique | 2004 - Century Media Records | 9/10 | 8.39/10 | 8.28/10 |
| |
| Iron Maiden |
| The History Of Iron Maiden - Part 1 (... | Heavy-Metal | 2004 - EMI | 4.75/5 | 4.75/5 | 4/5 |
| |
| Isen Torr |
| Mighty & Superior (EP) | Epic Heavy Metal | 2004 - Shadow Kingdom Records / Metal Supremacy | 4.5/5 | -/5 | -/5 |
| |
| It Dies Today |
| The Caitiff Choir | Emo/Metalcore | 2004 - Trustkill Records | 7/10 | 7.5/10 | 6.46/10 |
| |
| K-Again |
| Memories of an Evolution | Metallospaghetticore | 2004 - 2KK Records | -/10 | -/10 | 6.58/10 |
| |
| Katatonia |
| Brave Yester Days (Compil.) | Compilation déjà culte | 2004 - Avantgarde Music | -/5 | -/5 | 3.96/5 |
| |
| Kemet |
| The Night Before... | Dark Sensual Metal | 2004 - Thundering Records | 7.5/10 | -/10 | 6.9/10 |
| |
| Khams |
| T.O.C. (Démo) | Fusion | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 3/5 |
| |
| Korobskura |
| Démo (Démo) | Death mélodique | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | -/5 |
| |
| La Quiete |
| La Fine non è la Fine | Screamo | 2004 - Heroine Records | 9/10 | -/10 | 9/10 |
| |
| Lunatic Age |
| Peau Neuve | Rock | 2004 - AT(h)ome | 6.5/10 | 3/10 | 7.13/10 |
| |
| Machinae Supremacy |
| Deus Ex Machinae | SID metal | 2004 - Autoproduction | 7.5/10 | 7.5/10 | 8.67/10 |
| |
| Maroon |
| Endorsed By Hate | Metalcore | 2004 - Alveran Records | 7.5/10 | 8.5/10 | 7.03/10 |
| |
| Mary Slut |
| Regards de la terre | Fusion planante | 2004 - Jerkov Musiques | 6.5/10 | -/10 | 7.06/10 |
| |
| Meshuggah |
| I (EP) | Metal Progressif | 2004 - Fractured Transmitter Recording Company | 4.5/5 | 3.69/5 | 4.07/5 |
| |
| Midwinter |
| Fountain of Youth | Heavy metal symphonique | 2004 - Thundering Records | 6.5/10 | -/10 | 5.34/10 |
| |
| Ministry |
| Houses Of The Molé | Metal indus | 2004 - Sanctuary Records | 7.5/10 | 6.6/10 | 7.84/10 |
| |
| Mnemic |
| The Audio Injected Soul | Néo/Indus technique | 2004 - Nuclear Blast Records | 6.5/10 | 6.5/10 | 7.19/10 |
| |
| Moonlight |
| Audio 136 | Trip-Rock | 2004 - Metal Mind Productions | 7.5/10 | -/10 | -/10 |
| |
| Moray Firth |
| Inner Lands (Démo) | Progressive Dark metal | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 3.38/5 |
| |
| Mortiis |
| The Grudge | Indus/Gothique | 2004 - Earache Records | 6.5/10 | 6.5/10 | 5.93/10 |
| |
| Motörhead |
| Inferno | Hard - Rock N'Roll | 2004 - SPV | 8.5/10 | 8.29/10 | 7.6/10 |
| |
| Nagsnail |
| Démo (Démo) | Rock Métal | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | -/5 |
| |
| Nightwish |
| Once | Metal Symphonique | 2004 - Nuclear Blast Records | 5.5/10 | 7.3/10 | 8.43/10 |
| |
| No Forgiveness |
| Masquerade (Démo) | Indus-métal transalpin | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 2.25/5 |
| |
| Nydvind |
| Eternal Winter Domain | A la Belenos | 2004 - Adipocere Records | 8/10 | 8/10 | 7.7/10 |
| |
| Oestre |
| Génération Spontanée (Démo) | HxC Indus | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 3/5 |
| |
| On Thorns I Lay |
| Egocentric | Metal gothique | 2004 - Black Lotus Records | 5/10 | -/10 | 6.52/10 |
| |
| Orphanage |
| Driven | Death/Goth | 2004 - Nuclear Blast Records | 8.5/10 | 6/10 | 7.36/10 |
| |
| Orphaned Land |
| Mabool | Heavy/death oriental | 2004 - Century Media Records | 8/10 | 8.77/10 | 8.69/10 |
| |
| Oversoul |
| Me[n]tal Medication | Power métal | 2004 - Night and Day / Slalom Music | 7.5/10 | 7.75/10 | 7.26/10 |
| |
| Peccatum |
| Lost In Reverie | Metal expérimental aux multiples influences | 2004 - Mnemosyne Productions | 8.5/10 | 6.5/10 | 8.28/10 |
| |
| Psylaw |
| Sculptures | Traktopelcore | 2004 - Night and Day | 7.5/10 | -/10 | 6.81/10 |
| |
| Rammstein |
| Reise Reise | Metal Industriel | 2004 - Motor Music | 8/10 | 7.78/10 | 7.34/10 |
| |
| Red Mourning |
| Red Mourning (Démo) | Raw Power Metal | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 3/5 |
| |
| Relevant Few |
| The Art Of Today | Grind | 2004 - No Tolerance Records | 7/10 | 7.5/10 | 7.13/10 |
| |
| Rhapsody |
| Symphony Of Enchanted Lands II | Metal Symphonique | 2004 - Steamhammer Records (SPV) | 7/10 | 7.3/10 | 8/10 |
| The Dark Secret (EP) | Metal Symphonique | 2004 - Steamhammer Records (SPV) | 3.25/5 | 3/5 | 4.06/5 |
| |
| Riverside |
| Out Of Myself | Rock progressif | 2004 - The Laser's Edge | 7.5/10 | 8.6/10 | 8.48/10 |
| |
| Saber Tooth |
| Saber Tooth (Démo) | HxC | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | -/5 |
| |
| Scorngrain |
| Cyberwarmachine | Cyber Metal | 2004 - Dynamic Arts Records | 6.5/10 | -/10 | 6.16/10 |
| |
| Seraphim |
| AI | Heavy metal avec chant féminin | 2004 - Magnum / Arise Records | 8/10 | -/10 | 7.21/10 |
| |
| Sludge |
| Yellow Acid Rain | Sludge | 2004 - Mighty Music | 7/10 | 6.5/10 | 7.28/10 |
| |
| Small |
| Demo (Démo) | Powercore | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | -/5 |
| |
| Strange |
| Strange (Démo) | Brutal Deathcore | 2004 - Autoproduction | -/5 | -/5 | 3.19/5 |
| |
| Subterranean Masquerade |
| Temporary Psychotic State (MCD) | Metal progressif psychédélique | 2004 - The End Records | 4/5 | -/5 | 4.3/5 |
| |
| Textures |
| Polars | Metal technique | 2004 - Listenable Records | 7.5/10 | 8/10 | 7.97/10 |
| |
| The Aerium |
| Song For The Dead King | Metal gothique symphonique | 2004 - Black Lotus Records | 5/10 | -/10 | 4.15/10 |
| |
| The Destiny Program |
| The Tracy Chapter | Metalcore | 2004 - Lifeforce Records | 7/10 | 7.75/10 | 6/10 |
Par gulo gulo
Par AxGxB
Par Ikea
Par witch99
Par Jean-Clint
Par Ikea
Par Sosthène
Par Jean-Clint
Par Sosthène
Par Sosthène
Par Lestat
Par Sosthène
Par BBB
Par Sosthène